KINDERTOTENLIEDER

from sorrow to serenity to radiant joy

May 8, 2027, 7:30 pm

St. Mark’s Church, San Francisco

  • Anna Clyne’s Within Her Arms (2008) is a luminous elegy for string ensemble—music born from grief yet filled with tenderness. Written in memory of her mother, the work unfolds as a continuous meditation, its 15 strings moving in slow, breathing gestures that seem to cradle the silence between notes. The piece opens with fragile, overlapping lines—each phrase a thread of mourning—and gradually grows into moments of radiant intensity before subsiding once more into stillness.

    Clyne described the piece simply as “music for my mother, with all my love,” and that intimacy permeates every measure. The texture is transparent yet deeply expressive, reminiscent of early sacred polyphony but infused with the emotional directness of modern minimalism. Without words, Within Her Arms communicates profound compassion, its gentle dissonances resolving like sighs of acceptance.

    Rather than dramatizing grief, Clyne allows it to breathe—finding beauty in vulnerability, solace in unity. The music seems to hover between memory and release, evoking both the ache of loss and the quiet strength of love that remains. In its restraint and sincerity, Within Her Arms becomes not only a personal elegy but a universal expression of remembrance, holding the listener tenderly in its embrace.

  • Benjamin Appl, baritone

    Gustav Mahler’s Kindertotenlieder (Songs on the Death of Children), composed between 1901 and 1904, is among the most profoundly intimate works in the orchestral song repertoire. Setting poems by Friedrich Rückert, who wrote them after the loss of his own children, Mahler transforms private grief into transcendent art. The five songs trace a journey from anguish and disbelief to acceptance and spiritual calm—each one painted with delicate orchestration and psychological depth. Mahler’s music balances heartbreak and restraint, allowing emotion to unfold through luminous textures, fragile melodies, and moments of startling stillness.

    In the hands of Benjamin Appl, one of today’s most expressive baritones, this cycle becomes a deeply human meditation on love, loss, and remembrance. Appl’s warm, burnished tone and exquisite command of text illuminate the quiet dignity at the heart of Mahler’s vision. His interpretation captures the paradox of these songs: their sorrow is immense, yet never without light. With every phrase, Appl invites listeners to share in the tender reconciliation between despair and peace that Mahler so hauntingly evokes. Kindertotenlieder remains a testament to music’s capacity to transform personal tragedy into universal compassion—a work that consoles even as it breaks the heart.

  • Composed in 1811–12 and premiered in Vienna in 1813, Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony stands as one of his most rhythmically driven and viscerally exhilarating works. Richard Wagner famously called it “the apotheosis of the dance,” and the description fits: from the expansive introduction to the electrifying finale, rhythm is the animating force.

    The first movement begins with a broad, searching introduction that gradually gathers momentum before bursting into a propulsive Vivace. Syncopations and repeated rhythmic cells generate a sense of unstoppable motion, as if the orchestra has tapped into a kinetic current that cannot be restrained.

    The second movement, Allegretto, became instantly popular at its premiere. Built on a steady, processional rhythm, it unfolds as a set of variations over a persistent pulse. Its restrained intensity—somber yet luminous—creates a powerful contrast to the outer movements and offers one of Beethoven’s most memorable orchestral utterances.

    The Scherzo is explosive and unpredictable, juxtaposing muscular vitality with unexpectedly expansive Trio sections. The finale, marked Allegro con brio, is pure propulsion: driving rhythms, surging scales, and blazing orchestration combine in a whirlwind conclusion that feels less like a formal ending than an ecstatic release of accumulated energy.

    The Seventh remains a testament to Beethoven’s ability to transform rhythmic insistence into transcendent joy.

The Music

Benjamin Appl

Baritone Benjamin Appl is celebrated for a voice that “belongs to the last of the old great masters of song” with “an almost infinite range of colours” (Suddeutsche Zeitung), and for performances “delivered with wit, intelligence and sophistication” (Gramophone magazine). A former BBC New Generation Artist (2014-16), Wigmore Hall Emerging Artist and ECHO Rising Star (2015-16), Benjamin was also awarded Gramophone Award Young Artist of the Year (2016). He signed exclusively to Sony Classical in the same year and has since begun a multi-album deal with Alpha Classics, releasing his first album Winterreise in February 2021 to enormous critical acclaim.

Appl’s musical journey began as a young chorister at the renowned Regensburger Domspatzen, later continuing his studies at the Hochschule für Musik und Theater München and the Guildhall School of Music & Drama in London. Mentored by the legendary artist Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, Appl describes the partnership as an ‘invaluable and a hugely formative influence. He [Fischer-Dieskau] is an inspiration – someone who is always searching and seeking a deeper understanding of music and of life. He was a role model for how to prosper as an artist, never just delivering, but each time creating.’

An established recitalist, Appl has performed at Ravinia, Rheingau, Schleswig Holstein, Edinburgh, Heidelberg Frühling and Oxford International festivals; Schubertiade Schwarzenberg and at the KlavierFestival Ruhr. He has performed at major concert venues including Grand Théâtre de Genève, Festspielhaus Baden-Baden, Wigmore Hall London, Concertgebouw Amsterdam, Konzerthaus Berlin and Vienna, Elbphilharmonie Hamburg, Musée de Louvre Paris and at Shanghai Symphony’s Music in the Summer Air Festival.

In equal demand as soloist on the world’s most prestigious stages, his recent collaborators include the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra/Klaus Mäkelä, Munich Philharmonic/Andrew Manze, Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse/Ton Koopman, Budapest Festival Orchestra, Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra/Andreas Reize, NHK Symphony Orchestra/Paavo Järvi, Philadelphia Orchestra/Yannick Nézet-Séguin, Staatskapelle Dresden/Christian Thielemann, Philharmonia/Maxim Emelyanychev, Seattle Symphony/Thomas Dausgaard, Vienna Symphony/ Karina Canellakis and many others.